The flag-planting of activists in Scarborough Shoal (Panatag Shoal) in the South China Sea is not likely to jeopardize the Philippines’ arbitration case against China, according to a US analyst.
“I think that an act of population demanding its rights, if anything, should influence the verdict in its favor. I think it strengthens the Philippines’ bargaining position. I think it strengthens the case,” said Anders Corr, founder of risk consultancy Corr Analytics, in a podcast posted by The Diplomat.
Corr was the only foreigner who joined the activists in Scarborough on June 12, Independence Day, where they were confronted by the Chinese Coast Guard.
Scarborough Shoal was the site of a standoff between the Philippines in China in 2012 and has been occupied by the latter since.
The shoal lies within the 200-nautical mile exclusive economic zone of the Philippines but is also claimed by China.
“Although it would be a nonlegal influence, but I do think it would have a positive effect on the Philippine case and once it’s decided it will be a basis of social movement basis for insisting on getting the claim,” he said.
Without a “social movement,” the analyst said China might influence the Philippine government to back off from its claims.
“But if there’s a social movement holding leadership to account, I don’t think you’re going to see a very easy way for the Philippines to walk away from its claims from Scarborough,” Corr said.
Philippine security analyst Rommel Banlaoi said the incident was separate from the arbitration case.
“What the Filipino youth did in the Scarborough Shoal was an assertion of Philippine sovereignty while the arbitration case pertains to the clarification of Philippine maritime entitlements in the disputed waters in the South China Sea including the Scarborough Shoal,” he said.