Naked prisoners in Cebu jail cause uproar

The sight of naked prisoners during the Cebu Provincial Detention and Rehabilitation Center (CPDRC) greyhound operation on Tuesday dawn drew criticisms from Amnesty International.
/Contributed photo

Photos showing hundreds of prisoners in a Philippine jail sitting naked while being searched for contraband have triggered accusations of further rights abuses in President Rodrigo Duterte’s deadly war on drugs.

The inmates of the Cebu Provincial Detention and Rehabilitation Center (CPDRC) were woken before dawn on Tuesday, herded into the jail’s quadrangle and forced to strip while anti-drug agents, police and military searched their cells, prison officer Rafael Espina told AFP.

Photos released by the Philippine Drug Enforcement Agency and provincial police showed the inmates sitting naked and cross legged in neat rows on the concrete quadrangle, illuminated by spotlights, as armed police guarded them.

A statement released by the drug enforcement agency said the raid had netted “several packets” of methamphetamines and marijuana leaves, as well as knives and mobile phones.

With the photos gaining traction on social media, human rights groups voiced concern.

“This incident clearly amounts to cruel, inhumane and degrading treatment of prisoners,” Amnesty International said in a statement.
Yogi Felimon Ruiz, director of the Philippine Drug Enforcement Agency in Central Visayas (PDEA-7), said that asking detainees to take off their clothes was made for security reasons.

“Hubuan na kay magkagubot unya. Naay usa sa akong mga taw mentras nag-search, unya ang inmates wala gahubo sa ilahang sanina unya naa diay nakasakbit nga hait na hinagiban, madungaban akoang taw? (We asked them to take off their clothes as a security measure. I cannot allow my men to frisk inmates who may be hiding bladed weapons on their clothes because they could get hurt),” he said.

While they look after the welfare of detainees, Ruiz is also asking AI to also consider PDEA-7 agents’ safety.

“Mag sige silag insist nga na-violate namo ang human rights (of inmates), among right to protect ourselves balewalaon nalang usab (They insist that we have violated the rights of the detainees but what about our rights to also protect ourselves)?” Ruiz added.

If AI thinks that they know better, Ruiz said, they better lead the next CPDRC greyhound operation.

Amnesty cited United Nations’ standards and Philippine laws in highlighting the obligation of authorities to ensure prisoners were not subjected to torture or ill-treatment.

Human Rights Watch also said international standards prohibited searches that intimidated or unnecessarily intruded upon a prisoner’s privacy.

“The conduct of these searches — out in the open and permitting photographs to be taken — was inhuman and degrading and violated the prisoners’ rights to privacy,” Human Rights Watch said in a statement.

PDEA spokesman Derrick Carreon said the stripping of the inmates was on the order of the provincial governor and the guards.

“We just provide technical expertise,” he said.

Provincial government information officer Jethro Bacolod told AFP the mass stripping was “an SOP,” or standard operating procedure for raids to detect contraband.

He said the prison warden had been sacked because of the contraband that was found during the raid.

The Cebu prison became famous in 2007 due to popular YouTube videos showing inmates performing choreographed dances to hits such as Michael Jackson’s “Thriller.”

Duterte has been waging a controversial war on drugs that has seen police and unidentified assailants kill thousands of people over the past eight months.

Amnesty has warned the killings may amount to a crime against humanity.

Duterte, who remains popular with many Filipinos, has said human rights must take a backseat to defeating the much greater menace of illegal drugs ravaging society.