Carbon Alliance: ‘Supplemental MOA has no essential difference to defective JVA’

By: Wenilyn B. Sabalo - CDN Digital Multimedia Reporter | August 12,2022 - 10:35 AM

Artist Impression of a redeveloped Carbon Public Market | Photo courtesy of Megawide Construction Corporation

CEBU CITY, Philippines — Carbonhanong Alyansa, the primary vendor group opposing Megawide’s redevelopment of the Carbon Market, maintained that the recently signed supplemental memorandum of agreement (MOA) has “no essential difference” to the original Joint Venture Agreement (JVA) entered into by the City and the Megawide Construction Corp.

The group, in a statement on Thursday, August 11, 2022, said that both remain “equally disturbing and fearsome” to them as the Supplemental MOA still gives them no guarantee of their livelihood.

“First, provisions privatizing Carbon remain. Management and control of the project is still with SM-Megawide for 50 years. It is still Megawide that collects and receives all revenues from the project including those of the new market,” reads a portion of the statement.

Cebu City Mayor Michael Rama and Megawide signed the 15th City Council-approved supplemental MOA for the Carbon Public Market modernization last July 31, 2022.

READ: Megawide pours additional P3B into Carbon modernization, turns over P50M to Cebu City

The supplemental MOA was drafted to “cure” the original JVA of defective provisions that the Carbon market vendors’ alliance have brought to the attention of the City Council.

The supplemental MOA removes the provision in the original JVA that would have stopped the development while anticipating the return of profit from a certain phase. Additionally, Megawide’s investment in the project doubles from P5 billion to P8 billion as a result.

This ensures that the development will continue regardless of whether a unit has already been occupied by renters.

The city will also get at least P50 million annually, subject to ten percent increases beginning in the 11th year of operations and every five years thereafter.

However, the Carbonhanong Alyansa said the the supplemental MOA still gives no guarantee that no vendor or helper currently making a living in Carbon market will lose their livelihood in the new market.

Sought for comment, Joworski Alipon, the public affairs and public relations lead of the Cebu2World, a wholly-owned subsidiary of Megawide, said: “We have already explained in many occasion in the past our goal of providing a better Carbon without sacrificing the livelihood of the vendors. Everything that we are doing is for the good of Cebu.”

Among the other points raised by the Carbon alliance is the alleged failure of the Market Authority to forward to the City Council the promised master list of registered vendors, the demolition and conversion of Carbon Units 1,2, and 3 buildings into commercial units, the alleged drop in income of ambulant vendors after they were relocated, and the absence of stipulated limit to the percent increase in rent and other fees, among others.

The group then demanded that Rama to produce for their verification the master list of all vendors that have stalls in Carbon, produce the floor plan of the new market that shows the stall numbers of every vendor, and the moratorium on rentals and other fees for a period of 10 years.

“Do not ignore us, but arrange to dialogue with Megawide and stakeholders, especially Carbon-hanon, on what can be done about our rightful demands,” the group said.

/bmjo

Related stories:

Cebu2World to help promote products of relocated Carbon market vendors

Supplemental MOA to ‘cure’ Carbon Market JVA good as signed — Rama

Carbonhanong Alyansa to Garganera: Market JVA is also a human rights issue

Carbon Market supplemental MOA changes fate of vendors, Sitio Bato residents

Rama disappointed of delay of Carbon Market supplemental MOA

Read Next

Disclaimer: The comments uploaded on this site do not necessarily represent or reflect the views of management and owner of Cebudailynews. We reserve the right to exclude comments that we deem to be inconsistent with our editorial standards.

TAGS: Carbon Market redevlopment, Carbonhanong Alyansa, Cebu Daily News, Cebu2World, JVA, Megawide, supplemental MOA

We use cookies to ensure you get the best experience on our website. By continuing, you are agreeing to our use of cookies. To find out more, please click this link.